1 / 2The Killer Is Still Checked in: Murder Mystery Logic Puzzle
The Killer Is Still Checked in is a murder mystery logic puzzle built around a hotel register of 4,860 suspects and 17 clues. Eliminate guests by deduction until one name remains. The listing describes a screen-free puzzle book set in a 1930s New York hotel, with an online verdict and Solver Certificate offered after submitting your answer.
At a glance
- Solve a fictional murder by working through 17 clues and crossing suspects off a hotel register.
- The register lists guests by name, occupation, floor and room, according to the listing.
- The hotel setting is a grand New York hotel in 1934, during its Golden Jubilee.
- The listing says every clue is needed for a unique solution and offers an online verdict after entering the final suspect.
Reference price: $26.39
Price checked: 18 Nov 2026
View offerAhead of Black FridayExplore the selectionOften bought together
Pros and cons
Pros
- The elimination format makes this an active logic-solving challenge rather than a mystery to read passively.
- A large suspect register and a set of sequential clues give the puzzle a substantial deduction framework.
- The listing describes the register as full-size and uncrowded, supporting a layout intended for marking and comparing entries.
Technical specifications
9 specifications| Publisher | Independently published |
|---|---|
| Publication date | 11 July 2026 |
| Language | English |
| Print length | 183 pages |
| ISBN-13 | 979-8186782766 |
| Weight listed | 280 g |
|---|---|
| Dimensions | 15.24 x 1.07 x 22.86 cm |
| Suspects | 4,860 |
|---|---|
| Clues | 17 |
What to know before buying
- The answer check and Solver Certificate are described as available through a companion website, so solving the puzzle does not appear to rely on a printed spoiler page.
Who is it for?
A good fit for
- Readers looking for a murder mystery they solve through logic and elimination.
- Fans of whodunits, classic Golden Age settings and screen-free brain teasers.
- Puzzle solvers comfortable comparing a large suspect register against a sequence of clues.
Less suited to
- Readers wanting a conventional narrative mystery rather than an interactive deduction puzzle.
- Anyone who prefers a short puzzle with only a small set of suspects.

Customer reviews on Amazon
- 5 stars
53% 53% - 4 stars
21% 21% - 3 stars
15% 15% - 2 stars
0% 0% - 1 star
11% 11%
Aggregate customer ratings are mixed overall, with a majority in the top rating category but a noticeable share at the lowest category. The small rating sample does not explain the reasons behind those opinions, so it cannot establish whether the large-register deduction format or the online answer check suits a particular solver.
Frequently asked questions
How does the puzzle work?
Use the 17 clues to eliminate impossible suspects from the hotel register until one name remains. The listing says the clues lead to a unique solution.
What is the setting?
The mystery is set in a grand New York hotel in 1934 during its Golden Jubilee.
How can I check my final answer?
The listing says you can submit your final suspect on a companion website to get an instant verdict and a personalized Solver Certificate.
Is this mainly a story to read?
The listing presents it as a case to solve, not a conventional story. Its core activity is comparing clues with the guest register.
Alternative options

Unsolved Case Files Quick Play: Who Murdered Luna Knight? | Cold Case Murder Mystery Game
$20.04

Unsolved CASE Files | Doe, Jane - Cold Case Murder Mystery Game - Can You Solve The Crime? Who Killed Jane Doe?
$27.28

Unsolved Case Files | Ivey, Sandra - Cold Case Murder Mystery Game | Can You Solve The Crime (I5-08102021)
$34.99

Unsolved CASE Files | Gardner, Avery - Active Murder Mystery Case - Can You Solve The Case?
$34.99

Unsolved CASE Files: Cold Case Murder Mystery Game: Who Murdered Harmony Ashcroft? | Can You Solve The Crime?
$34.99

The Killer Chose A Baby Name: A Murder Mystery Puzzle Book: An Interactive Whodunit for Armchair Detectives: Eliminate Suspects and Cross Off Names Until Only One Remains
$23.55

The Lottery Killer Volume 4: An Immersive Christmas Heist Logic Puzzle | Crack 9,600 Passwords, Trace 1,920 Transactions and Unmask the Founder
$25.29

























