
We Could Be So Good: A Novel
We Could Be So Good is a historical romance novel about Nick Russo, a Brooklyn reporter, and Andy Fleming, the newspaper mogul’s son who joins the newsroom. Set in the late 1950s, their growing friendship and love unfold against the risks of being gay in a hostile era.
At a glance
- A romance centred on Nick, a reporter, and Andy, the son of a newspaper tycoon.
- Set in a late-1950s newsroom, with secrecy and social hostility shaping the relationship.
- The listing presents it as a tender, character-focused story that develops from an unlikely friendship.
Reference price: $36.99
Price checked: 18 Nov 2026
View offerAhead of Black FridayExplore the selectionOften bought together
Pros and cons
Pros
- The newspaper workplace ties the central romance to both characters’ careers and family pressures.
- Its late-1950s setting makes the risks around Nick and Andy’s relationship part of the story’s conflict.
- Customer feedback highlights readable prose, emotional depth and authentic characters.
Cons
- Customer feedback includes mixed views on pacing, with some finding the story slow.
Technical specifications
8 specifications| Publisher | Avon US |
|---|---|
| Publication date | 13 October 2023 |
| Language | English |
| Print length | 384 pages |
| ISBN-10 | 0063272768 |
| ISBN-13 | 978-0063272767 |
| Weight listed | 1.05 kg |
|---|---|
| Dimensions | 13.49 x 2.18 x 20.32 cm |
Who is it for?
A good fit for
- Readers looking for a gay historical romance set in a late-1950s newsroom.
- Readers drawn to character-led stories about secrecy, family expectations and a relationship developing from friendship.
Less suited to
- Readers who prefer consistently brisk pacing, as some customer feedback describes this story as slow.
Customer reviews on Amazon
- 5 stars
66% 66% - 4 stars
26% 26% - 3 stars
7% 7% - 2 stars
1% 1% - 1 star
0% 0%
Customer feedback highlights readability, emotional depth, authentic characters and well-executed writing. Some comments appreciate the portrayal of gay love and realistic arguments. Pacing draws mixed reactions, with several describing it as slow. For readers seeking a character-led historical romance, that slower pace may suit the relationship’s development, but it may be less appealing if you want a consistently fast-moving plot.
Positive themes
- Customers praise the book’s readability and emotional depth.
- Customers describe the characters as authentic and the writing as well-executed.
- Some customers appreciate its portrayal of gay love and relationships.
Mixed feedback
- Pacing receives mixed reactions, with some customers finding the story slow.
Frequently asked questions
What is We Could Be So Good about?
Nick Russo is a reporter at a major city newspaper, and Andy Fleming joins the newsroom at his father’s insistence. Their friendship develops into a romance they must decide whether to fight for openly.
When and where is the story set?
The story is set in the late 1950s and follows the characters in a New York newspaper newsroom.
How long is the listed edition?
The listing gives a print length of 384 pages.
What do customers say about the pacing?
Feedback is mixed. Some customers describe the pacing as slow, while other comments praise the book’s readability and emotional story.
Alternative options

Star Shipped: A Novel
$25.85

After the Siren: A spicy MM romance for fans of Heated Rivalry (Brunswick Falcons book 1)
$21.24

Boyfriend Material: 1
$23.75

Swimming in the Dark: Selected for Dua Lipa's Service95 Book Club 2024
$18.39

See you at the Finish Line: A new enemies to lovers sporting romance with a perfect love story
$22.75

Descended: For some, the veil between realms is stretched thin… (Coming-of-Age Fantasy)
$26.09

The Wren: Historical Western Romance (1)
$53.98

If Walls Could Talk: The Dunmara Series - Book 1
$11.99

Theo of Golden: THE MILLION-COPY BESTSELLING PHENOMENON
$14.99

The Underdog: The debut novel from the award-winning food writer – ‘A joy to read’ Rukmini Iyer
$28.33

The Existential Worries of Mags Munroe: The Mags Munroe Series
$11.99

Yesteryear: The million copy #1 Sunday Times Bestseller
$14.59

























