1 / 2My Favorite Color is Mistletoe: YA Christmas Rom-Com, A Favorite Color Novel #3
My Favorite Color is Mistletoe is a YA Christmas rom-com in the A Favorite Color Novel series. Audrey and Jax team up for a double fake date over Christmas, amid family competitions, an ex and Audrey’s long-time crush. The listing describes it as a clean, dual-point-of-view romance that can be read in any order.
At a glance
- A holiday romance built around a double fake date that begins to feel real.
- The plot includes a family Christmas gathering, a couples’ competition, Jax’s ex and Audrey’s childhood crush.
- Described as a clean YA romance told from dual points of view.
- The series novels are presented as readable in any order.
Reference price: $21.15
Price checked: 18 Nov 2026
View offerAhead of Black FridayExplore the selectionOften bought together
Pros and cons
Pros
- The festive fake-dating setup gives the romance a clear central hook.
- The listing identifies the story as clean and age-appropriate for teen readers.
- Can suit readers wanting a holiday romance without needing to start with an earlier series novel.
Technical specifications
9 specifications| Publisher | Sara Watterson |
|---|---|
| Publication date | 26 September 2025 |
| Language | English |
| Print length | 280 pages |
| ISBN-13 | 979-8985747485 |
| Reading age | 12 - 17 years |
| Grade level | 7 - 11 |
| Weight listed | 327 g |
|---|---|
| Dimensions | 13.97 x 1.78 x 21.59 cm |
What to know before buying
- The listing describes the book as appropriate for teens and tweens, but individual comfort with romance themes can vary. See the author’s additional content information if that matters to your household.
Who is it for?
A good fit for
- Readers looking for a clean YA Christmas romance with humour and family holiday scenes.
- Teen and tween readers who enjoy fake dating and childhood-crush storylines.
- Readers who prefer romances told from two points of view.
Less suited to
- Readers seeking a non-romance plot or a story without holiday themes.

Customer reviews on Amazon
- 5 stars
78% 78% - 4 stars
15% 15% - 3 stars
4% 4% - 2 stars
2% 2% - 1 star
1% 1%
Customer feedback is positive about the series and its clean, age-appropriate romance. The aggregate ratings are also mostly five-star, though ratings alone do not explain individual readers’ reasons. This feedback may be useful to buyers seeking a teen-friendly romance, but it does not establish how every reader will respond to this book’s specific themes or humour.
Positive themes
- Customer feedback praises the series’ content and romance, particularly its clean, age-appropriate approach.
Frequently asked questions
What is the story about?
Audrey and Jax arrange a double fake date over Christmas break. Their pretence is complicated by family holiday events, Jax’s ex and Audrey’s childhood crush.
Is this described as a clean romance?
Yes. The listing describes it as a clean YA Christmas romance and directs readers to the author’s additional content information for more detail.
Do I need to read the earlier books first?
The listing says the My Favorite Color novels can be read in any order.
What are the listed age and length?
The listing gives a reading age of 12 - 17 years and a print length of 280 pages.
Alternative options

Sweet Temptation: Weybridge Academy #2: The second heartstopping book in the elite boarding school forbidden romance series from the author of the best-selling Darling Devils
$12.00

Rebel Darling: Darling Devils #4: The 4th book in the best-selling YA ice skating meets ice hockey sports romance series, DARLING DEVILS, new for 2026!
$15.99

My Favorites Stories: By Carmen Thompson Beckles
$14.08

Sweet Heartbreak: Weybridge Academy #1: The first heartstopping book in the elite boarding school forbidden romance series from the author of the best-selling Darling Devils
$12.00

Sweet Ruin: Weybridge Academy #3: The swoony, dramatic finale to the elite boarding school forbidden romance series from the author of the best-selling Darling Devils
$12.00

A Good Girl's Guide To Murder Deluxe Special Edition: The best-selling YA crime thriller – now a new edition with exclusive extras. The perfect Christmas gift for 2026!: Book 1
$35.00

I Hate You More: A feel-good enemies to lovers YA rom com from the author of the best-selling DARLING DEVILS
$9.00

























