1 / 2A Very Bookish Murder: Scottish Cozy Mystery, Book 3
Cozy: A Very Bookish Murder is the third Scottish cosy mystery featuring Ally McKinley, a Highland guesthouse owner drawn into a writers’ retreat murder investigation. Its bookish setting, amateur sleuth and layered suspects suit readers after a character-led cosy crime story.
At a glance
- Set in the Highland village of Locharran, where guesthouse owner Ally McKinley investigates the murder of a novelist during a writers’ retreat.
- The plot centres on rivalries, accusations of plagiarism and infidelity, a diary with missing pages and a second death.
- Book three in the Ally McKinley series, with the author’s description presenting it as a standalone cosy mystery.
Reference price: $18.69
Price checked: 18 Nov 2026
View offerAhead of Black FridayExplore the selectionOften bought together
Pros and cons
Pros
- A clearly defined cosy-crime premise combines an amateur sleuth, a writers’ retreat and a Scottish Highland setting.
- The 238-page print length offers a relatively compact read for buyers choosing by listed length.
Technical specifications
8 specifications| Publisher | Bookouture |
|---|---|
| Publication date | 16 September 2025 |
| Language | English |
| Print length | 238 pages |
| ISBN-10 | 183618252X |
| ISBN-13 | 978-1836182528 |
| Weight listed | 236 g |
|---|---|
| Dimensions | 12.85 x 1.52 x 19.84 cm |
Who is it for?
A good fit for
- Readers of cosy mysteries with amateur sleuths, bookish settings and Scottish Highland atmosphere.
- Readers who enjoy continuing series characters and a clue-led murder plot.
Less suited to
- Readers seeking a standalone literary thriller or a non-crime story.
- Readers who prefer to begin a series at its first instalment.

Customer reviews on Amazon
- 5 stars
59% 59% - 4 stars
28% 28% - 3 stars
11% 11% - 2 stars
2% 2% - 1 star
0% 0%
Customer feedback is positive about the storytelling, readability, characters and mystery, with the supplied summary mentioning a clever plot and twists. The rating pattern is mostly favourable but includes a notable middle-rating share, so reception is not uniformly enthusiastic. That feedback may help readers choosing a character-led cosy mystery, but it does not establish that every reader will enjoy the series.
Positive themes
- Customer feedback praises the clever, twist-filled storyline and the characters.
- Readability and the mystery are also identified as positive themes.
Frequently asked questions
Which instalment is A Very Bookish Murder?
The listing identifies it as book three in the Scottish cosy mystery series featuring Ally McKinley.
What is the story about?
Ally hosts writers attending a nearby retreat and becomes involved when novelist Jodi Jones is murdered. A second death and missing diary pages deepen the investigation.
How long is the book?
The listing gives a print length of 238 pages.
Is this book suitable for readers new to the series?
The supplied description presents it as an enjoyable cosy mystery in its own right, but it is the third instalment, so readers who prefer following character development from the start may want to begin earlier.
Alternative options

The Turning of our Bones (DI Rob Marshall Scottish Borders Police Mysteries Book 1)
$1.49

Aspire to Die: An Oxford Murder Mystery (Bridget Hart Book 1)
$3.99

Pelican Cove Cozy Mystery Series Box Set 1: Books 1-4 in Pelican Cove Cozy Mysteries
$0.99

The Dotty Sayers Antique Mysteries Boxset (Books 1–6): A British Cozy Mystery Collection with a Female Amateur Sleuth in the Cotswolds (Dotty Sayers Antique Mystery Boxsets Book 1)
$12.99

Sophie, Standing There: The highly anticipated new novel from the international bestselling author of Sorrow and Bliss, now a Reese's Book Club pick
$9.00

The Bessiere Files: COUNCIL OF LIES
$27.49

Holly, Baubles and Murder
$22.99

The Murder Hotel: Was it the pyromaniacal under manager? The herbicidal chef? Or someone else... (Samantha and Daisy Cosy Mysteries Book 1)
$4.13

Sam Wick Boxset 1: Book 1-3 (The Sam Wick Series Box Set)
$9.99

The Asset (Lance Spector Thrillers Book 1)
$7.99

























