1 / 7SHEGLAM True Stain Liquid Lip Liner, 505 But First,Coffee
SHEGLAM True Stain is a liquid lip liner in shade 505 But First,Coffee, listed as a pencil with a matte finish. Its listing promotes long wear and smooch-proof colour, while also describing a gloss-like shine, so buyers should note the finish claims do not align clearly.
At a glance
- The listing identifies shade 505 But First,Coffee and a matte finish.
- Pencil format is listed for applying lip colour with liner precision.
- The product is claimed to provide one-swipe colour and long-wearing, smooch-proof wear.
- The listing describes the design as compact for touch-ups.
Reference price: $13.99
Price checked: 18 Nov 2026
View offerAhead of Black FridayExplore the selectionPros and cons
Pros
- Compact listed dimensions suit carrying for touch-ups.
- A matte finish and a named shade make the intended look easier to assess before buying.
Technical specifications
12 specifications| Brand | SHEGLAM |
|---|---|
| Model | sb260413144943132976945 |
| Shade | 505 But First,Coffee |
| Product type | Lip Liner |
| Item form | Pencil |
| Finish | Matte |
| Product benefit | Long wearing |
| Dimensions listed | 12.6 x 2.6 x 1.5 centimetres |
|---|---|
| Weight listed | 1.7 Grams |
| Skin type | Normal |
|---|---|
| Number of items | 1 |
| Heat sensitive | No |
What to know before buying
Listing details to confirm
The listing is inconsistent about finish and format: it calls the item a matte pencil and liquid lip liner, but also describes a liner-and-gloss combination with shine. One-swipe payoff and smooch-proof wear are product claims, not confirmed performance.
Who is it for?
Customer reviews on Amazon
- 5 stars
60% 60% - 4 stars
11% 11% - 3 stars
13% 13% - 2 stars
4% 4% - 1 star
12% 12%
The aggregate ratings are broadly positive but include a noticeable spread across lower star categories as well. Without customer-comment detail, they do not identify specific strengths or explain concerns. Treat the ratings as limited context rather than evidence of how the listed matte, long-wearing claims perform.
Frequently asked questions
What shade is this lip liner?
The listing names the shade as 505 But First,Coffee.
Is the finish matte or glossy?
The details specify a matte finish, but a feature claim also describes shine and a gloss-like function. The listing does not resolve this inconsistency.
What is the listed item form?
The product details list the item form as Pencil, while the title calls it a liquid lip liner.
Does the listing confirm long wear?
Long wear and smooch-proof wear are claims in the listing. They are not independently confirmed here.

Alternative options

SHEGLAM Fall In Line Peel Off Lip Liner Stain Long Lasting Transfer-proof Nude Lip Tint-Pinky Promise
$7.99

medicube Wrapping Mask Collagen Overnight Peel Off Facial Mask | Elasticity & Hydration Care, Reduces Sagging & Dullness | Hydrolyzed Collagen For Glowing Skin | Korean Skin Care, 75ml
$22.90

SHEGLAM Love Stained Lip Tint Marker Matte Red Lip Stain Pen Highly Pigmented Long-Lasting Lip Liner Contour Tint Lip Makeup-It Girl
$12.79

SHEGLAM Cloudline Blur Lip Liner Long Lasting,Vegan & Cruelty-Free Lip Stain-Ember Cloud
$13.59

SHEGLAM Hydra Jelly Pocket Lip Jam-Watermelon Whirl
$7.93

SHEGLAM Lip Liner Creamy Matte Pencil High Pigment Not Easy to Fade Silky Smooth Matte Contour Tint Lip Makeup-Neutral
$12.74

SHEGLAM PoutPerfect Moisturizing Solid Lip Gloss Non Sticky Lipstick with Coconut Oil-Spring Fever
$9.38

SHEGLAM Fall In Line Peel Off Lip Liner Stain Long Lasting Transfer-proof Nude Lip Tint-Chocoholic
$7.99

SHEGLAM Cloudline Blur Lip Liner Long Lasting,Vegan & Cruelty-Free Lip Stain-Ash Canvas
$13.59

Jutqut Matte Lipstick Pen, Long Lasting and Waterproof Lip Stick Pencil, Non-Stick Cup Velvet Lipsticks, Smooth Creamy Stain Finish Lip Colour Crayon, Highly Pigmented Lipliner, Soft Blurred Effect 04
$9.34

TIMEPHORIA Lunara Frost 3D Lip Gloss, 005 Artemis - Warm Pink, High-Shine Glossy Finish, Juicy Pigment Lip Gloss with 3D Plumping Effect, 24H Hydration with Hyaluronic Acid, Non-Sticky Cushiony Gel
$18.90
























