1 / 6eXtremeRate Black Replacement Thumbsticks for PS5 and PS4 Controllers, 4 Count
Count: eXtremeRate replacement thumbsticks are a four-piece black set listed for PS5 and PS4 controllers. They are intended as internal replacements for worn or damaged sticks, so installation requires opening the controller rather than fitting an outer grip.
At a glance
- Four black replacement thumbsticks for compatible PS5 and PS4 controllers, according to the listing.
- Designed as an internal replacement, not an external stick cap. Opening the controller is required.
- Listing package details name a screwdriver and prying tool alongside the sticks.
Reference price: $17.99
Price checked: 18 Nov 2026
View offerAhead of Black FridayExplore the selectionOften bought together
Pros and cons
Pros
- Four pieces provide replacements for more than one stick or a spare set.
- The listing claims compatibility with PS5 and all PS4 model controllers.
- Customer feedback describes installation as easy and the parts as durable.
Cons
- Installation involves opening the controller, which is more involved than fitting an external grip or cap.
Technical specifications
4 specifications| Brand | eXtremeRate |
|---|
| Compatible devices | PS5, PS4 |
|---|---|
| Material listed | Plastic |
| Colour | Black |
What to know before buying
Listing details to confirm
The listing describes the material inconsistently: the details specify Plastic, while feature text names PC and TPE plastic and another section says ABS. Its package text also varies between a screwdriver and prying tool list and the instruction that a screwdriver is included, so confirm the material and selected package contents before buying.
Who is it for?
A good fit for
- PS5 or PS4 controller owners replacing broken or cracked thumbsticks.
- Buyers seeking black replacement sticks and willing to open a controller for installation.
Less suited to
- Anyone looking for slip-on thumbstick covers that do not require internal fitting.
- Buyers who need confirmed compatibility with controller models other than the listed PS5 and PS4 devices.

Customer reviews on Amazon
- 5 stars
67% 67% - 4 stars
16% 16% - 3 stars
12% 12% - 2 stars
0% 0% - 1 star
5% 5%
Customer feedback highlights easy installation, including use of step-by-step instructions, and perceived durability. That may matter for a DIY replacement, but the listing says internal fitting is required and customer impressions do not establish tool contents or compatibility for a particular controller revision.
Positive themes
- Customers describe installation as easy.
- Customers describe the parts as durable.
Frequently asked questions
Which controllers are these thumbsticks listed for?
The listing states compatibility with PS5 and PS4 controllers, including all PS4 model controllers. Confirm your specific controller before ordering.
Are these external stick covers?
No. The listing describes internal replacement parts and says the controller must be opened for fitting.
What tools are included?
Package text lists a screwdriver and prying tool, while another instruction mentions a screwdriver. The tool contents are therefore not fully consistent in the listing.

Alternative options

eXtremeRate Black Thumbsticks Replacement Kit for PS5 for PS4 Controller Analog Stick Joystick Custom Thumbstick Cap Grips Cover
$9.19

Mcbazel 7 in 1 Thumbsticks Replacement Kit for PS5 Controller Joystick Repair Tool Kit Analog Stick Thumbstick Cap Grips Cover - Black
$9.59

Replacement Joystick Caps for PS5 PS4 Controller, 6/10 PCS Thumb Grips, Anti-Slip Wear-Resistant TPE Material, for Gaming Controller Accessories
$10.19

eXtremeRate ThumbsGear Interchangeable Thumbsticks for PS5 Edge Controller, Replacement Black Analog Thumb Sticks Caps for PS5 Edge Controller - 4 Heights 3 Surfaces Grips - Without Thumbstick Base
$22.09

GoyaWhite 6 Pcs PS5 Thumb Grips, Analog Caps for PS5 & PS4 Controller | Non slip textured joystick caps, durable replacement accessories for game controllers to prevent scratches and fingerprints.
$9.99

eXtremeRate ThumbsGear Interchangeable Ergonomic Thumbstick for Xbox Series X & S/Xbox One/Xbox One Elite/Xbox One S & X Controller with 3 Height Domed and Concave Grips Adjustable Joystick - Black
$3,994.00

7-in-1 Comprehensive Thumbstick Repair Kit for PS5 Controllers: High-Quality Replacement Set Featuring Durable Anti-Wear Analog Stick Caps, Ergonomic Grips, Professional Screwdriver Tools
$5.94

ThumbsGear Joystick Grips for PS5 & PS4 Controllers, Interchangeable Ergonomic Thumbsticks with Height Options, Domed & Concave Caps & T6 T8 Screwdriver Repair Tool Set
$14.49

NEWDERY Joystick Replacement Cap Thumb Grips for PS5/PS4 Controller | 10PCS, Anti Slip, Diamond Texture, Anti Scratch, Anti Fingerprint, TPU Grip Caps, Joystick Covers, for PS5/PS4 Controllers
$21.24

Thumb Grips, Thumb Cover, Silicone Thumbstick Caps Accessory Set 12 Pcs | Performance Joystick Controller Cap Replacement Compatible with Ps5 & Ps4, Xbox, Steam Deck Etc (2 Colors)
$11.99

4 Pairs Controller Thumbsticks for PS5 Controller,Black Replacement Custom Analog Stick Joystick Compatible with PS5 (8pcs)
$6.57

Yxvyxymyxxg TMR Hall Effect Joystick for Nintendo Switch/OLED/Lite Joy-Con, Zero Drift Replacement Thumbsticks with Tools Kit, 1 Pair, Black
$15.39
























