# A Whispering of Trees: A Family Tragedy and the Girl Who Survived

Family Tragedy Girl Survived: A Whispering of Trees is a true-crime account of the 1971 killing of six-year-old Charlie Benedek and the subsequent life of his sister Susan, who witnessed the shooting. Drawing on records and interviews, it follows her experience in state care and examines institutional failures.

- [Original product page](https://aussiedealscout.com/product/a-whispering-of-trees-family-tragedy-girl-who-survived)
- [View offer](https://aussiedealscout.com/visit/a-whispering-of-trees-family-tragedy-girl-who-survived)
- Market: AU
- Language: en-AU
- Currency: AUD
- Category: [Books, Music & Hobbies &gt; Books, Music & Movies &gt; Books & Comics](https://aussiedealscout.com/books-music-and-hobbies/books-music-and-movies/books-and-comics)
- Price: 28.25 AUD
- Previous price: 36.99 AUD
- Discount: 24%
- Price checked: 2026-11-18T07:07:35.113Z
- Rating: 4.6 / 5
- Reviews: 14

Prices and deal status are the latest recorded data, not a guarantee of availability. Confirm the price and availability with the store.

## At a glance

- Recounts the 1971 family tragedy and its impact on Susan, who witnessed her brother’s death at age four.
- Covers Susan’s years in state-run facilities and the failures of institutions meant to protect her.
- The listing says the account draws on court transcripts, psychiatric files, government records and interviews.

## Pros

- A substantial 366-page account combining the personal story with examination of child welfare and institutional responses.
- The listed source material spans legal, psychiatric and government records as well as interviews.

## Specifications

### Publication details
- Publisher: Big Sky Publishing
- Publication date: 26 May 2026
- Language: English
- Print length: 366 pages
- ISBN-10: 192351458X
- ISBN-13: 978-1923514584
### Dimensions and installation
- Weight listed: 390 g

## Before you buy

- The subject matter includes the deliberate killing of a child, bereavement, abuse and neglect, which may be distressing for some readers. The listed publication date is 26 May 2026.

## A good fit for

- Readers interested in Australian true crime and historical cases.
- Readers seeking a narrative focused on a survivor’s life and child welfare systems.

## Less suited to

- Readers who prefer to avoid detailed accounts of violence against children, trauma or institutional neglect.

## Customer feedback

Aggregate ratings lean favourable, with most ratings in the top category, but a smaller portion are low ratings. Without written customer feedback, the reasons for either response are unclear. Treat the ratings as a limited signal rather than evidence of particular strengths or shortcomings in this account.

### Rating distribution

- 5 stars: 74%
- 4 stars: 17%
- 3 stars: 0%
- 2 stars: 9%
- 1 star: 0%

## Frequently asked questions

### What is A Whispering of Trees about?
It recounts the 1971 killing of Charlie Benedek, witnessed by his four-year-old sister Susan, and follows the effects on Susan’s life, including her time in state care.
### What sources does the book say it uses?
The listing says it draws on court transcripts, psychiatric files, government records and interviews.
### How long is the book?
The listed print length is 366 pages.
### Who publishes A Whispering of Trees?
The listed publisher is Big Sky Publishing.

## Alternative options

- [THE INDUSTRY OF FALSE HOPE: Before you pay another guru, read this. Expose the discovery call scripts, fake scarcity, and legal traps driving the modern coaching empire.](https://aussiedealscout.com/visit/a-whispering-of-trees-family-tragedy-girl-who-survived)
- [Grewoo Western Cowboy Backdrop Banner, 8X6FT Wild West Rustic Wooden Barn House Photography Background for Western Party Decoration, Rodeo Backdrop for Kid Birthday Party](https://aussiedealscout.com/visit/a-whispering-of-trees-family-tragedy-girl-who-survived)
- [Cat Pet Print Gift Wrapping Paper Roll, 43cm x 5m Matte Present Wrap Roll for Birthday Holiday DIY Gift Box Decoration](https://aussiedealscout.com/visit/a-whispering-of-trees-family-tragedy-girl-who-survived)
- [50 Pcs Cowboy Boot Decorations,DIY Wild West Cowpoke Boots Paper Cutout,West Cowboy Themed for Bulletin Board Decor,Cowpoke Party,Wild Occident Themed Party Essentials Supplies,Bulletin Board Cutouts](https://aussiedealscout.com/visit/a-whispering-of-trees-family-tragedy-girl-who-survived)
- [OSYLICT 72 Pieces Cute Cat Writing Paper and Envelopes, 8.3x5.6 Inch Stationery Set, 48 Lined Sheets & 24 Envelopes, Kitty Design for Letters, Invitations, Gifts, Holidays, Party Notes](https://aussiedealscout.com/visit/a-whispering-of-trees-family-tragedy-girl-who-survived)
- [21 Pack Western Cowboy Party Decorations for Birthday Rodeo Favors \| West Cowboy Themed Party Hanging Swirls, Wild West Ceiling Streamers for Adults Cowgirl](https://aussiedealscout.com/visit/a-whispering-of-trees-family-tragedy-girl-who-survived)
- [The Critical Thinking Effect: Uncover The Secrets Of Thinking Critically And Telling Fact From Fiction](https://aussiedealscout.com/visit/a-whispering-of-trees-family-tragedy-girl-who-survived)
- [SPSS Made Easy: A Practical Guide to Statistical Analysis for Students and Researchers](https://aussiedealscout.com/visit/a-whispering-of-trees-family-tragedy-girl-who-survived)
- [THE INDUSTRY OF FALSE HOPE: Unmasking the Actors, Algorithms, and Predatory Traps of Modern Coaching](https://aussiedealscout.com/visit/a-whispering-of-trees-family-tragedy-girl-who-survived)
- [Buziba 30Pcs West Cowboy Western Photo Booth Props Kit Wild West Party Decorations Selfie Props Party Favors Supplies](https://aussiedealscout.com/visit/a-whispering-of-trees-family-tragedy-girl-who-survived)

## Images

![A Whispering of Trees: A Family Tragedy and the Girl Who Survived — 1](https://aussiedealscout.com/i/H3bL36anwHgtkuDzJ98mX5Tgf2Enne3a16GXhuC2h37hsfTPcKw5GDQZunrsZt59bQfWlqUgfvYO9B5OF0hCSSVHbwEWvvv-mCW5OsHxX5wLVBrlJkZt.jpg)
